Marathon Real Estate - Pamela Nada-Caley

This is our second major real estate transaction in which we have worked with Pam and she is nothing short of spectacular!! Pam goes above and beyond all of our expections for a full service Realtor. Thanks to Pam, we navigated through the many obstacles and closed on the property.

I want to thank Coldwell Banker Schmitt for retaining such a talented real estate professional as Pam Nada-Caley, and my wife and I want to thank Pam for providing us such professional and thorough support. We now call Pam our friend and recommend her services to anyone interested in buying property in the Keys.

- Thomas & Myra R.

"Pam worked with us for about 5 years on both an attempted purchase and on the sale of our house. We have bought & sold a dozen houses and Pam is the Best sales agent we have ever had. Pam is perceptive of the market and guided us accordingly. She puts a lot of effort on our behalf. Pam is fun to be around and that is important. She knows contract work and she picked up mistakes by the other side on several occasions. Pam got us out of a messy situation when trying to buy a house where the facts were miss stated by the seller. You are lucky to have Pam on your staff. I would recommend her and have to anyone in Marathon planning to buy or sell a house. Best Regards Myrna & Tom"

Patty

I own a home in South Florida and wanted to buy another in the Florida Keys. Did not really dream it was possible. I'm a nurse. So nursing salary... All I had was a 5% down payment. All the other Realtors turned me away. Pam held my hand,, I mean she pulled up info like a lawyer would!! And I now have my dream home. I'm now looking for one more investment property. Pam is the only one I will trust to be in it for me,,not the money,,,, I wish anyone who needed a realtor could call me for my testimonial.... Tytytytytytyty pam. :-*

Lynn B.

Pam was incredible! She dealt with 2 out-of-town sellers, one nutsy buyer, presented multiple offers, negotiated as instructed, and then was called into service "above and beyond" when she donated furnishings and fixtures and had all belongings removed per the Sellers' wishes. Would I recommend Pam? Absolutely! Without hesitation!

David & Susan H.

Pam was wonderful. Always available and exceptionally helpful and well-informed."

Mary and Bruce B.

"Pam was extremely thorough in researching properties we might be interested in. Pam's researching of the property we purchased was beyond our expectations!"

Ervin C

"Pam is outstanding!"

Tim and Dan

"Clone Pam! She's great. This was our 7th home purchase and Pam is far and above any other agent we've had!"

Aref J.

"Make sure that all the Sales Associates follow Pam Nada-Caley's principals. Ms. Nada-Caley is an asset for your company."

Joan and Ed B.

"Pam Nada-Caley was excellent."

Dan & Mary D.

“Loved working with Elaine, Pam and her associates.”

Edward & Joan B

“We have previously bought a house with Pam. She is very thoughtful and answers any questions we have.
She is the best!”

Edward & Joan B.- Buyers

“We have dealt with Pam Nada Caley for years.
She is the best!”

William & Teresa M.

Pam was amazing! She showed up on a Sunday!
Excellent communication

Joan & Edward B.

Pam is the BEST!”

Mark S.

GREAT JOB!

Mark S.

Great Job!

David & James G.

Thank You Pam!

Daniel T.

I had an awesome experience with Pam. She is on top of the real estate market. She is knowledgeable, kind and fun to talk to. I will recommend Pam to my neighbors, family and friends. Great Work and Thank you!

Catherine & Herbert B.

We cold not be happier with Elaine, Pam & Chase. Everything was explained thoroughly, and our questions were answered. Chase & Pam were diligent in ensuring everyone was appropriate for showing. Everyone was responsive to our calls.

Jerold D. & Sally L.

Pam is the BEST! We used her service inbound, several years before. She has been our best realtor in 6 home purchases and 5 home sales. Very thorough in checking permits and survey status. Pam is like one of the family.

Our Blog

Blog Categories

© 2025 CB Schmitt Real Estate Company, Inc. Equal housing opportunity. An equal opportunity company.

© 2025 CB Schmitt Real Estate Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Coldwell Banker® and the Coldwell Banker Logo are registered service marks owned by Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC. CB Schmitt Real Estate Company, Inc. fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and Equal Opportunity Act. Each franchise is independently owned and operated. Any services or products provided by independently owned and operated franchises are not provided by, affiliated with or related to Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC nor any of its affiliated companies.

MLS Internet Data Exchange (IDX) information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the Florida Keys Board of Realtors.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site come s in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the Marathon and Lower Keys Association of REALTORS®, Inc. MLS. Real Estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Schmitt are marked with the MLS logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker’s office.

BEST REAL ESTATE DEALS YOU NEED TO DO IS VERY SIMPLE JUST JOIN US

Open Houses

New Listings

Luxury Properties

Agents

New on Market

House

House in Duck Key94 Antigua StreetDuck Key, FL 33050

Town House

Town House in Duck Key5018 Sunset Village Drive, D-050Duck Key, FL 33050

Featured Listings

Town House

339 25Th StreetMARATHON, FL 33050

Town House

271 2nd StreetKEY COLONY, FL 33051

Town House

22 SadowskiKEY COLONY, FL 33051

Town House

5035 Sunset Village DriveDuck, FL 33050

Town House

Address UnavailableMARATHON, FL 33050

Town House

1133 W Ocean Drive, 5KEY COLONY, FL 33051

Town House

3 E Kyle WayMARATHON, FL 33050

Town House

261 & 271 9th StreetKEY COLONY, FL 33051

- Bruce S.

- Thomas & Myra R.

Patty

Lynn B.

David & Susan H.

Mary and Bruce B.

Ervin C

Tim and Dan

Aref J.

Joan and Ed B.

Dan & Mary D.

Edward & Joan B

Edward & Joan B.- Buyers

William & Teresa M.

Joan & Edward B.

Mark S.

Mark S.

David & James G.

Daniel T.

Catherine & Herbert B.

Jerold D. & Sally L.

Our Blog

Blog Categories

Property Portal

Top Areas

Featured Agents

Real Estate

Contact

Pamela Nada-Caley

House in Duck Key 94 Antigua Street
Duck Key, FL 33050

Town House in Duck Key 5018 Sunset Village Drive, D-050
Duck Key, FL 33050

339 25Th Street
MARATHON, FL 33050

271 2nd Street
KEY COLONY, FL 33051

22 Sadowski
KEY COLONY, FL 33051

5035 Sunset Village Drive
Duck, FL 33050

Address Unavailable
MARATHON, FL 33050

1133 W Ocean Drive, 5
KEY COLONY, FL 33051

3 E Kyle Way
MARATHON, FL 33050

261 & 271 9th Street
KEY COLONY, FL 33051